Thank you so much for your thoughtful comments on my previous post. I love getting input from others when something is puzzling me about the knitting world (or just the world) and you all gave me several more points to think about with your comments. I don’t plan on writing up a similar hoodie anytime soon, but this is a fun learning process.
I continued making modifications, because I know what I like and I just can’t stop. I’m almost done with the hood, then I’ll make the ears, weave in ends, and show you what I’ve done! I ended up reworking the pocket a bit. I made it a little shorter at the top, and I picked up the required stitches to knit it straight onto the body, rather than knitting it as a separate piece and sewing it on. Sometimes I’m all about the shortcuts and ease of finishing. With a kiddo knit, it seems to me like it’s not necessary to work it in so many separate pieces to get the best fit, and since they’re such quick knits, I don’t want to spend a lot of time finishing. So far I’ve been able to do this with almost no seaming, and I love that.
While all of this is happening, this morning I decided it was time to rip back the shawl collar on the design for Matt’s sweater.
For my own sweaters, I just can’t deny that seams and glorious glorious set-in sleeves just fit me best, and I’ll do the extra work necessary to get that fit. I ADORE knitting in the round for the quickness, ease, and reduced finishing, but with some garments, like my Liesl, the knitting in the round gives it a bit of twist when you wear it. When you knit in the round, you’re making one big spiral. Sometimes that spiral becomes evident when you wear the garment.
Seams have another advantage. They keep the garment from sagging over time. This Shine dress might have been saggy over time without the stabilization of seams, especially since it is half cotton. For a Still Light Tunic that I knit, I did a provisional cast on and bound it off at the neck later (since it is a top-down raglan) to help give stability to the dress over time. On occasion, I’ll make a “fake seam” by putting a purl stitch in where a seam might be. I did this on the Treeline Cardigan centered under the armpit. It won’t give your garment extra stability, but in this case it serves as a helpful guide when re-blocking after a wash. I think that’s an Elizabeth Zimmerman technique, but I’m too lazy to hunt down the reference for you all.
I love top-down raglans for the trying-on potential as you knit it, but the shoulders never fit me quite as well. I’m eager to try Blank Canvas to see if this pattern can change my mind about the fit of raglan sleeves. My first set-in sleeve was on Larch Cardigan and that thing fits me better than any other sweater. I’m sold. It’s trickier to design, trickier to seam, but it’s WORTH IT. Trust me, or try it yourself. This video cleared up a lot of questions for me about seaming set-in sleeves.
If anyone wants to test knit for the Dapper Man sweater design, I’m taking volunteers. It’s full of seams and set-in sleeves. I can’t provide compensation aside from singing praises about you and giving you a free pattern, so do it only if you have a fella you’re dying to knit this for. I’m going to try to release the pattern to test knitters by mid September, with a goal of releasing the final pattern by mid-late October, even if test knitters aren’t finished with it at that point. I plan on having chest (in inches) sizes 36 (40, 44, 48, 52, 56, 60). Please email me at cassy AT knitthehellout DOT com if you are interested and let me know which size you would be interested in knitting. I’d like to try to have 1-2 people knitting each size.
I just love geeking out about knitting. Happy knitting!